What we do

At Extra Virgin, with our home at Old Mistick Village, CT and Peddler’s Village, PA; our philosophy is simple; everyone should have the opportunity to sample the best olive oil and balsamic vinegars from around the world before deciding on their personal favorites. Think of our store as a tasting emporium, a stroll through an authentic Mediterranean marketplace.

We take immense pride in bringing products to our customers that they cannot find anywhere else. Olive oils and vinegars from Spain, Italy, Greece, and Portugal, coupled with specialty oils from award-winning Executive Chefs throughout the United States. This is not your grocery store oil and vinegar, this is the good stuff – the stuff that you want on your family table.

What your grandmother used on her table.

Sweet Honey

Sweet Honey

With a variety of honey & other accenting flavor combinations, we let you discover your next new favorite with us!

Savory Oils

Savory Oils

Our goal is to offer the best olive oil and balsamic vinegar from around the world.

Get Curated Recipes

Get Curated Recipes

When you need sauces, olive oil & vinegar, look no further, there’s a reason why we’ve been voted the BEST in New England!

Extra Virgin – Mystic, CT

(860) 536-1916

Extra Virgin – Lahaska, PA

(267) 544-0661

Awesome honey shop! The flavors are so creative and so delicious. I'm not sure if it was a special or an everyday thing, but I had the opportunity to taste any and all the honies I wanted. The staff were very friendly and very knowledgeable and I felt the prices were fair. I will definitely be coming back to stock up.
Martin Moore

Love the personalized service. Who knew that tasting Honey or Olive Oil or Vinegar could be as exciting a tasting wine. They also carry Mustards, Pastas and Sauces.  They do ship nationwide.

Melissa Fray

The moment I arrived their friendly staff explained how to pair the olive oils they sell. You can mix and match what you want and they will box it up for you. They give you many ideas on how to pair their oils with what you are making for dinner. If you need some pasta or meat sauce, they have that too! I purchased some Peppermint honey while there and loved it!

John stevens